Best Dessert Shops in Fort Myers

We have hand-picked our favorite dessert shops in Fort Myers and what made the list is pretty amazing. Pretty sure we found the best ice cream ever made, an amazing homemade cookie shop, churros, and much more!

Love Boat Ice Cream Fort Myers

Love Boat Ice Cream

Love Boat Ice Cream is a cherished gem in the heart of Southwest Florida, serving up some of the most delectable ice cream you’ll ever taste. This isn’t just an assumption; it’s a fact backed by the line of eager locals and excited visitors that you’ll find queued up outside their doors almost every day. Each scoop is a testament to the craftsmanship and passion that goes into creating their truly mouth-watering treats. The moment you step into Love Boat, you’re not just entering an ice cream shop – you’re joining a community of dessert enthusiasts who know where to find the best ice cream in town.

Address: 7977 Dani Dr Unit 130, Fort Myers, FL 33966
Address: 16475 San Carlos Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33908

Peter’s German Ice Cream & Coffee Shop

In the heart of Downtown Fort Myers lies a charming establishment known as Peter’s Ice Cream and Coffee Shop. This delightful spot is not only popular for its freshly made coffee and delectable ice cream. It’s also known for the warm and inviting atmosphere created by the extremely friendly owners.

The best part? They extend their hospitality to our four-legged friends, making it a welcoming place for puppies as well.

If you find yourself exploring downtown Fort Myers, Peter’s Ice Cream and Coffee Shop is an absolute must-visit. Whether you’re in need of a caffeine boost or craving a sweet treat during the evening, this adorable shop has got you covered. Its prime location and friendly ambiance make it an excellent stop for anyone visiting downtown Fort Myers.

Address: 1412 Dean St, Fort Myers 33901 | Phone: (239) 400-5282

Chloe's Cookies in Fort Myers

Chloe’s Cookies

It’s a haven for sweet tooths and dessert enthusiasts, nestled in the heart of Fort Myers. Their cookies aren’t just baked – they’re crafted meticulously, each one a perfect handful of sweet and savory goodness that leaves you craving for more. The moment you step through their doors, you’re greeted with the irresistible aroma of freshly baked cookies, a clear testament to the love and dedication poured into each batch. The secret, perhaps, lies not just in their unique recipes, but also in the high-quality ingredients they insist on using.

Address: 8260 College Pkwy, Fort Myers, FL 33919 | Phone: (239) 206-1030

Heavenly Biscuit in Fort Myers

Heavenly Biscuit

With a menu that caters to the early risers, they’ve become a beloved spot for those seeking a hearty start to their day. But it’s not just about the biscuits at this quaint establishment. They have also managed to carve out a niche for themselves amongst dessert lovers, with their pecan rolls and cinnamon rolls being particularly popular. Each sweet treat is thoughtfully crafted, providing a delectable balance of sweet and savory flavors that delights the palate.

Yet, Heavenly Biscuits’ story is one of resilience. Prior to Hurricane Ian, it was a well-established brick-and-mortar diner, adored by many for its cozy ambiance and homestyle cooking. However, the hurricane brought about unexpected changes, compelling them to adapt in order to continue serving their community. Now operating out of a food truck, Heavenly Biscuits stands as a testament to the indomitable spirit of Fort Myers.

Despite the changes, their commitment to quality and taste remains unaltered, ensuring that every biscuit, every roll, continues to be as heavenly as ever. So, if you’re exploring the best dessert shops in Fort Myers, don’t miss out on this resilient food truck that keeps the tradition of delicious breakfast and sweet treats alive, one heavenly biscuit at a time.

Sun Harvest Citrus Ice Cream

Sun Harvest Citrus

This isn’t your regular store; it’s a paradise for citrus lovers! Whether you’re searching for freshly squeezed orange juice or other citrus-based products, Sun Harvest Citrus has got you covered. Their commitment to freshness and quality is unparalleled, ensuring that every purchase brings the authentic taste of Florida’s finest citrus fruits straight to your home.

But that’s not all! While primarily catering to those shopping for citrus items, Sun Harvest Citrus also offers a delightful surprise in the form of their popular ice cream stand. This little corner of sweetness serves up some of the most delicious ice creams that have become a hit with both locals and visitors alike. And if that wasn’t enough, they also have a selection of bakery goodies that are perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth. So, next time you’re exploring the best dessert shops in Fort Myers, do yourself a favor and swing by Sun Harvest Citrus. It promises not just a shopping experience, but a taste of the vibrant flavors that Florida has to offer.

Address:14601 6 Mile Cypress Pkwy, Fort Myers, FL 33912 | Phone: (239) 768-2686

Ice Spot(Rolled ice cream and bubble tea) cookie dough ice cream

Ice Spot(Rolled ice cream and bubble tea)

It’s an adventure waiting to happen! This gem offers a wide array of delightful treats that cater to all tastes. For those who have a penchant for unique beverages, Ice Spot’s specialty tea drinks are a must-try. Each brew is crafted with care, infusing traditional flavors with a contemporary twist that’s sure to tickle your taste buds.

But the fun doesn’t stop there. Ice Spot is also home to some of the best rolled ice cream in town. This isn’t your everyday ice cream experience – it’s a spectacle! The kids will be absolutely enthralled as they watch the staff expertly roll their chosen flavors into beautiful, delicious creations.

And if that wasn’t enough, Ice Spot also serves up mochi and donuts, making it a one-stop-shop for all things sweet. So, whether you’re looking for a refreshing drink, a frosty treat, or a classic dessert, Ice Spot has got you covered! Don’t miss out on this fun and flavorful destination when exploring the best dessert shops in Fort Myers.

Address: 13499 S Cleveland Ave UNIT 101, Fort Myers, FL 33907

Daddy Dee's Ice Cream Parlor

Daddy Dee’s Ice Cream Parlor

Stepping into Daddy Dee’s Ice Cream Parlor in North Fort Myers is like stepping into a time machine. This charming shop, which has been delighting customers for over 45 years, transports you back to the good old days with its classic train sets and vintage decor. As soon as you walk through the doors, you’re greeted by an ambiance that’s both nostalgic and inviting. The sight of the classic train sets whirring around will make you feel like a kid again, and the old-time decor adds a unique charm that makes every visit special.

But it’s not just about the ambiance, Daddy Dee’s also knows how to entertain its guests. Some nights, the air at Daddy Dee’s is filled with the harmonious sounds of an acapella group serenading customers with popular hits from yesteryears. It’s a delightful experience that adds an extra scoop of fun to your ice cream outing. From their delicious banana splits, sundaes, and old-time sodas, to their friendly service, and the unique entertainment, Daddy Dee’s Ice Cream Parlor is more than just an ice cream shop – it’s a trip down memory lane. So, if you’re exploring the best dessert shops in Fort Myers, don’t forget to add Daddy Dee’s to your list!

Address: 13161 N Cleveland Ave # 1, Fort Myers, FL 33903 | Phone: (239) 997-4021

Your Fort Myers Travel Advisors

Scroll to Top